Otel Academy · Episode 02

Why is AI fundamentally different for hotels?

Is AI in hotels overhyped? Otel AI CEO Paul Ryan finds out how Jonas Treffers, GM of Pillo Hotel, is using AI to spend more time with guests and his team.

Watch the full conversation with Paul and Jonas.

AI is different for hotels because it takes the routine off the team, so managers get time back for guests and staff. It only amplifies the expertise a team already has, and it can't replace the human connection guests come for. Jonas Treffers' advice for GMs: start small and hand AI the task you dislike most.

About this episode

Is AI in hotels overhyped? Jonas Treffers, GM of Pillo Hotel Ashbourne, says it’s underhyped, and that it’s really about people, not spreadsheets. Otel AI CEO Paul Ryan finds out how one GM is using AI to spend less time at his desk and more time with guests and his team.

Jonas believes that understanding your hotel’s data isn’t optional any more: it’s part of a manager’s job. He shares how his first steps with Copilot at Pillo turned hours of pickup and pace reporting into time for strategy. He also explains why AI gives a General Manager a more objective view of their hotel than gut feel alone.

They also get into the risks. AI can fool people who don’t yet have the industry experience to question it, so deep domain expertise matters more than ever. Jonas is clear that AI isn’t about replacing people. It changes the jobs people do. It can automate the routine, but it can’t automate the human connection guests come for.

For GMs who haven’t started yet, Jonas’s advice is simple: start small and hand AI the task you dislike most. The conversation ends with why one unified layer over your whole tech stack is what moves the P&L, plus a quick-fire round and his best advice for young hoteliers.

In this episode

Lightly edited for reading.

Paul Ryan

Jonas, thank you so much for giving up your time today to join us on our second episode of the Otel Academy, where we speak to industry experts on all things AI in hotels. I'd like to jump straight into it, if that's okay. For anyone who does not know the one and only Jonas, who are you?

Jonas Treffers

I'm a Dutch hotelier, living in Greystones now for gosh many moons now. And I fundamentally believe that hospitality is about people. And I think it's quite cool that we can talk today about AI and what that does, but I think fundamentally hospitality is about people and that is what I truly believe in.

Paul Ryan

I love it. Let me ask you a question. You've been working in hospitality for many years and you've seen a lot of tech come and go and different trends. Like when you see AI today, do you see it as just another fad, or do you think it's something that's fundamentally different and could change how you think and run hotels?

Jonas Treffers

I it the main thing it is for me, it ha it has enabled me to be able to get more out of my day to day job and actually get back what I joined the industry for. That is look after guests, look after people, work with my team and give them time. And I think that sure, a coffee machine or a cutlery polishing machine gives you back time, but that is a singular job or a singular task. I think this gives people tools and in particular now when an industry is evolving that is more techno based it gives a fundamental power there's a huge amount of data in this industry that you can't grasp as an individual between accounts to check ins to selling pints in a bar whatever it is that it's data and I think we are required as managers to understand this data have this data In the palm of our hands, it becomes impossible at a certain point to have this at the palm of your hands.

And I think AI enables you to have it and simplify this data, funnel it. So I think fundamentally this is a different kind of technology that the industry hasn't seen before. And of course it's wider used and only in the hospitality industry. But I think it's fundamentally different.

Paul Ryan

When we speak to other hotels, you know, maybe some are using AI, some aren't, and they're kinda asking us the question like what are people using AI for? Has there been anything that you have done in the last year in your hotel that has made a big difference, like a use case or where you've got efficiencies or whatever it may be?

Jonas Treffers

Well yeah, for sure. My team has done it a and I've done it. But I started using AI when it was in its not when it's in its infancy but when it became usable for Joe Public and I'm Joe part of the public. With ChatGPT I think in 2022 or something like that it was.

And it was very clunky, it was very gimmicky and quite dull and it was prone to a lot of mistakes and it didn't really work well. So what I started using it for, first for myself, was I started speaking to text. So I have a Word document open and summarize my Word document for various reports that I needed to write. And I could create far more structure in that way, far quicker, because it summarised my what I call word vomit on a page, pages and pages of text, and I it summarised it.

And it summarised it quite neatly and organised and therefore I could then play with it. But it has evolved since then. And I recently joined the Pillow Hotel here in Ashbourne and first couple of things which I did was I gave people Copilot, not widely Used within the team. I didn't give it to all 150 staff members that we have here.

But some senior managers and said, Look, let's play around with this and let's see what you can do yourself with it to ensure that your job becomes more manageable, that you have more opportunities to actually analyse your own job or that you can spend more time with your team or with the guest or wherever you want to invest this time in. And we then started to see people using it not only for emails, not only for summarising meetings, but to analyse data. And you see a sales and marketing manager suddenly putting her reports into Copilot and say okay fine if I do this I summarise this report but I add my emails to it and I add my workflows to it. Suddenly I get a different view of how the business is actually run.

And it's enthusiastic to see the revenue manager in the hotel, he came to a meeting completely enthused. He said, Kevin, why are you so enthused? Well I got a new presentation. Which he done with the help of AI, but suddenly the depth of data that he was able to analyse over a very short period of time was vast.

And therefore you have a different viewpoint and you can run your business differently.

Paul Ryan

Yeah.

Jonas Treffers

But it's cool to be able to see that, that people are starting to use it. And I think before I always believed that information is powerful when you share it, and these are technologies that I think you need to share. I think people are fooling themselves if it's only the GM or the senior team that uses it because people are gonna come in but ChatGPT or Meta AI or Groc or Claude in their own private accounts anyway and then start using it there. So why not give it to people that at least it's Safe in your surroundings with your Microsoft work environment or your Google if you're using Gemini or whatever it is.

So you might as well give it to people and then at least it's controlled.

Paul Ryan

There's different I think personas in hotels and you know one thing we try to do when we're onboarding is kinda meet each individual and kind of show them the art of the possible with AI. But I suppose how do you think about rolling out AI? Have you been met with any resistance

Jonas Treffers

No, absolutely. And I think in particular if I'm over a certain age that I had to buy into it for myself. I find that if I didn't that then I will be bypassed by people in five years, give or take. So I felt that I had to buy into this to not be an expert.

I don't think I'm an expert in AI at all, but at least I can use it and I can use it to my advantage. And I think that has enabled me now to be able to do these things and run my hotel in a certain way. I think fundamentally I cut my desk time by 70% easily. So I can walk around the hotel, have chit-chat with staff, give my time to staff, have lunch with people, give my knowledge to the team.

When I spent my time in the morning saying hello to the team, I'm not worrying about having to come back to a hundred emails or reports that need to be done or whatever it is, because A AI can do that. But I think we need to share that and we need to share that information and ensure that yeah it works for us. I think the people that didn't buy into it or haven't bought into it. I can understand it as well.

If you're of a certain age and let's say you work in finance or you work in a department which is very much data oriented and you need to analyse data and you've never done this and you see that sometimes or suddenly this tool can do the job that you do probably better, for sure quicker, that's daunting because suddenly you're fighting in inverted commas an enemy that you can't win from. And I think that's the danger. But you need to then as a leader, and that I'm pointing at myself, in this industry, you need to ensure that there's an understanding that you're not replacing people, but that you enable them to do other things. And therefore if this person would buy into it that he or she can then spend more time with junior staff members and explain to them what the reasonings are for it.

Because it's also the flip side. If you give it to a person that hasn't got the experience yet, AI can fool you very quickly. And that's I think a big danger if you're giving it to somebody that doesn't know the industry or any industry for that matter and you type in be an industry expert in X, Y, and Z and write me a report on whatever and that's being sent to you, you very quickly find out that it's nonsense what this person has sent to you and that it's written by AI. And I think you need to be careful with that because You're giving a very powerful tool to somebody that doesn't know how to run the industry.

And I think therefore you need to be wary of that.

Paul Ryan

Yeah, I think those kind of guardrails are really important. We might often get asked, you know, what's this going to do for my business? And I think it's like, what's the ROI? Do you know?

And there's so many 'cause say our product's kind of broad, there's different ways you can measure that. But I think ultimately AI is still in its infancy to be able to say, you know, categorically this is what it will do to your top line, bottom line, but categorically equally you can say if you adopt it and use it in the right way, there's so much more efficiency you personally can gain to which then you can spend your time on more strategic things, like we I was speaking to a hotel group this week that we're onboarding and they're spending like an hour and a half doing like pickup and pacing reports every day. Do you know? And that's just the way it's always been done.

So like that's a great use case for AI where okay they can spend that hour and a half now doing far more strategic decision making like whether it's rate strategy or you know whatever it may be. But I don't know whether you'd agree with that.

Jonas Treffers

No a hundred percent, but i if you take the hour and a half that it takes somebody to make a pace report, a pick-up report, etcetera, that is 18.7% of somebody's day. Take an 8-hour work day. If you just take that away and it's sent in your inbox, which I get now from Otel, I get a pace report, a GM report that I can alter in the way how I want to read it. That is 20% of somebody's day that you don't have to do anymore.

That is automated and then you can actually analyse it rather than having to pull this report and pull that report and analyse it with Copilot or whatever. So I think of course it's a use case. The 70%, it's a guesstimate. But what I do find for myself is that a lot of times we write reports that are retrospective.

We have to write a P&L report. How did last month go? What happened here? What happened there?

I need to do a I don't know, an appraisal with somebody. How has somebody been throughout the year? We're humans and maybe I'm different, but I don't remember exactly what happened on the first of January of this year. Let's be very clear on that.

So if you have an AI embedded in your system, you get a very objective view how somebody has been in meetings, how the tone of their email has been, how interactions have been, so suddenly you build up a far more objective and truer picture of a topic. Than what a person can do themselves. And I think you suddenly can see trends. You suddenly can see things that are happening for yourself.

And I started practicing for this for myself with AI to see where am I at and what are the red lines in my career or the red lines in my life. And I've built up the history in ChatGPT for a long time now. And I can actually see things in for myself as a jokey thing to say, okay, fine. I talk to it and said, okay, then this is my youth, this is where I am now.

What are the trends, etcetera. So I think it's quite cool to be able to play with it, but you need to you need to keep your feet firmly on the ground. It can't be i it is a software, ultimately. It's not alive, it's not a living creature.

It's a software.

Paul Ryan

No, I agree. Slightly looking into the future, I suppose, given like we said, AI is still in it in its infancy, but like do you have any views on, say, what you would let AI do on its own versus always needing someone like a human t to own, do you know, a human in the loop. Like, do you have any views on that?

Jonas Treffers

Well, I'm not Dario or Sam Altman that I know

Paul Ryan

Ha.

Jonas Treffers

Exactly what is gonna happen with AI or that they know which version that they've got rolling out in the next two years. But what I do think if you look at things that can be done now, if you have a routine job Let it be a pick-up report, let it be a pace report. Of course that can run ultimately without any pressing of a button. Yes, please run this report.

I think for yourself you need to check the data, but once you are convinced that this data is actually accurate and you've tested it over per period of time and you take I don't know Once a month or once a week, or whenever you feel that you need to do a test yourself that the data is correct, you can let those things run. I think what is interesting is two-way communication with agents in AI. I have a weekly report that I write for my ownership that is automated. I'm not writing that myself anymore, but once I get it, I alter it and I play around with it to say this part is not important this week, I leave that for next week, etc.

But these reports are done automatically. If you can update date your rates for instance, it sees the data, you've checked it that your rates in two, three, four, five months time need to be updated because the market has picked up hugely or has dropped hugely, that I think an AI can do that. And I would very quickly allow an AI to do that. And then people, in my opinion, because I when I introduced it here first and you were in that meeting, people straight away ask so you gotta get rid of staff.

It's not about that. I don't think it's about replacing people. It's about changing the jobs that people have. And I think if you're looking at a revenue manager, ultimately an AI can do that.

Absolutely. You can build an agent that says you're a revenue manager, you're doing this, you check the market, you update the pricing, etc. But it's not only that, it's also how does it interact with people in the office? How do we feel that we need to do things?

How do we feel that we need to set up a culture? An AI doesn't look you in the eye. And an AI doesn't have a soul. And I think that I bring it back to my opening statement.

I asked my team recently, about a month ago, okay guys, you're working with AI now, you've got Copilot, you've got Otel AI, how does this work for you? Are you happy with it? Are you not happy with it? Should we get rid of it.

And there was nearly anarchy when I said we're getting rid of it because people want to keep it, which is great. But I said, Okay, fine, so where is my ROI? And they all looked at me and they said, gosh, you're trying to cut costs here. I said, Far from it.

Like what is my ROI here in this Hotel from AI. And it is, in my opinion, it's time. But it's what do you do with that time? And what do you fundamentally invest that time in?

And if you say, well, I want to increase my own productivity, great, fantastic, go for it. But I think as a company, we need to invest that time in our people, and we need to invest that time in our guests, and we need to invest that time in our community. We need to invest that time in wherever we want to ensure that the human connection improves. And I think if you can Have an AI work in the background to answer certain emails that are standard, that are coming into your hotel on a daily basis, what time is breakfast or got whatever, people want to ask from a hotel that is standardised.

That can be done automated. But what you can't automate is the chat at the coffee machine. And that is something that I think people have been looking at their computer screen and their phone screens on a daily basis. That's why the like the knitting is coming back and people are doing pottery and people want to feel nature and they want to feel the person behind it.

And I think that is what people want. And therefore, yeah working from home and remote work is all well and good, but I think human connection is very important and there's a lot of loneliness out in the world. I think I'm not pushing people to say you have to be compulsory in the office, we're herd animals. We live in herds and

Paul Ryan

I totally agree. I totally agree. I sorry, slightly, completely off topic, but I'd kinda been that person for the last five or six years where I'm just I come home, see my kids, and then I work. And then about three months ago my wife said, Why don't you not go join the local football team?

I haven't played this team sport in about fifteen years and I'm not good. But what it allows me to do is that hour and a half on a Wednesday night, it's just pure escapism away from technology and that kind of community. And I think we run the risk with remote working, with AI, with technology of just yeah, losing that sense of the human connection. So sorry, just more to I totally agree with your mindset.

Jonas Treffers

That's true. And I think that therefore if you have that time and if you can find more human connection and if you can find the person behind the job title or if you can find the person behind the room number, i.e. The guest, and you have time for that, you can bridge a gap between luxury hotels and four star or three star hotels. It ultimately people like to be looked after.

Paul Ryan

Yeah.

Jonas Treffers

If you as a senior member of the team can assist a junior member of the team about the beauty of this industry and actually see how nice it is to look after each other and guests with that, yeah, that's what this industry is about ultimately. And I think that therefore like your hospitality can improve. And I think that is ultimately what we're here for to practice hospitality and to ensure that people are looked After and I think that's the main thing that we need to do as people in this industry is look after our guests. Because if we don't, somebody else will.

The guests pay our wages. That's simple. And if we don't look after them, somebody else will, and therefore I don't have wages anymore. Because that's our revenue.

It's as simple as that.

Paul Ryan

Simple as that. Yeah. We're coming close here now to the end. So I'm super conscious of your time.

Last question and then we'll go into some quick fires, if that's okay, the fun part. But so if you were to advise, say, another general manager who hasn't started AI, like what would that advice be? Like where should they start first? Do you have any views on that?

Jonas Treffers

Well start small and I think if you can take a task that is very mundane that you actually dislike but you have to do on a daily basis, a repetitive task. Let it be, I don't know, sending a reminder email, let it be calculating something, let it be whatever it is, or making minutes for a meeting, for a senior manager meeting that you say, I don't want other members to be in that and can we record this or can we do something like that and transcribing it and then sending out minutes. It's play around with that first. And I think Playing with it I think teaches you a lot.

I think ultimately children are very good at it. I don't have kids myself, but the playing human being finds out things in a different way and I think you need to play with it. There's not a lot that can go wrong currently with it in the environments that we have got. So the like there's a lot of guardrails in there now.

If you type in can I do X, Y, and Z if straightway comes up, probably no you can't, and that is why I can't do this or I can't provide with that. So there are guardrails in that already, so there's some kind of methodology behind it. But play around with it and see what you can do. And don't be afraid of it.

In the next two, three years the role of a general manager is not gonna go away. Plus, on top of that, I don't think it's gonna go away the next decade. But our role will fundamentally change. And I think when I went into the industry all those years ago in the Savoy in London, and you saw Mr.

Pajares in his Savile Row tailor-made suits and his handmade shoes, the person was behind clouds and you ever saw him, it was in his office and that was it. He walked in, you gave him a coffee, and then you left him, and the door was closed and it was you never knew what was happening. I think that fundamentally is changing. The GM needs to be out on the floor, needs to be with the guests, needs to be with his or her team members.

And if you can spend more time with that and if you can save more time through AI, do it. Because I think that is why we all joined this industry. I don't think at least I think or maybe I hope that no GM joined this industry to only do spreadsheets.

Paul Ryan

I fundamentally agree. AI in hotels right now, is it overhyped or in your view, is it under hyped?

Jonas Treffers

Underhyped.

Paul Ryan

This is a slightly controversial question, so feel free to give me a political answer. Front desk in 10 years, is it still there or is it gone?

Jonas Treffers

Still there.

Paul Ryan

One job in the how to AI should never touch.

Jonas Treffers

Kitchen Porter.

Paul Ryan

I love it. One task you'd hand to AI tomorrow if you could.

Jonas Treffers

I use AI so much, that there's no job that I wouldn't think of giving to AI, I've tried to use Otel AI as a stack. So the I was speaking to somebody from I can't remember who within your company and they said, yeah, it's great for revenue management and it gives you all this data. But I fundamentally believe it's far more than that. If it's a genie that sits on top of all these layers of data that a hotel has and it can read it and therefore see trends and pulls information to it, that's a P&L.

Ultimately. The P&L is the outcome of what you've done. So if it can pull the data from Sage, from your POS system, your PMS system, from your purchasing, from your rostering system and you can pull it. The only thing that I wouldn't connect to it probably is the bank because I think that at the moment still a bit precarious to be able to do that.

But that's your P&L and therefore if you can have a P&L at the press of a button at any stage it enables the accountant to actually analyse it.

Paul Ryan

Yeah.

Jonas Treffers

I think we're humans and we shouldn't let an AI run our life. But it can damn well be a very good assistant.

Paul Ryan

Last question. Best piece of advice you got as a young hotelier.

Jonas Treffers

Look after the guests because they pay your wages.

Paul Ryan

I'll be the tagline. I love it, Jonas. I love it. Come here, you're an absolute legend.

Thank you so much, man, for taking the time.

Jonas Treffers

Thank you, Paul. Thank you.

About the speakers

Paul Ryan

CEO and co-founder, Otel AI

Paul is the CEO and co-founder of Otel AI, the operating advantage for hotels: every system a hotel runs, in one view you can trust, with the work done on top. He puts the same questions to every room of hoteliers he speaks to, and the answers are the reason this episode exists.

Jonas Treffers

General Manager, Pillo Hotel Ashbourne

Jonas Treffers has over 20 years’ leadership experience across hotels, luxury resorts, F&B, and large-scale events. Originally from Amsterdam, he is known for high standards, strong commercial focus, and building supportive, high-performing teams. He previously served as General Manager of Aloft Dublin City, where he led the hotel post-opening, delivered strong guest satisfaction, and was named Operational GM of the Year at the Marriott Hotels EMEA GM Conference. Jonas is also a former Chair of the Dublin Branch of the Irish Hotels Federation and remains active in Ireland’s hospitality industry.